We tried Super Nannying Braysen again tonight. It went much better than it did at naptime. Here's how it played out:
The first few times he got out of bed, he knew exactly what to expect. When I went into his room to lay him back in bed, he smiled and laughed at me. This went on until about the 15th time I had to put him back. By then he started to become a little frustrated. By the 20th time I had to put him back in bed, he was full-on wailing.
The end score?
15 total minutes and 33 times of being put back in bed before he stayed in there and was out like a light within 3 minutes. :) Yay!
I'm hoping it continues to get better and better from here.